Home Blog Page 1715

Top EU Court upholds regulations on flavoured tobacco

0

An EU regulation that phases out the sale of flavoured “roll your own’’ tobacco is valid, the Top EU Court said on Wednesday, January 30, 2019.

Flavoured tobacco
Flavoured tobacco

The decision concerns a German firm, Planta Tabak, that filed a lawsuit protesting a 2014 EU prohibition on the sale of certain flavoured tobacco products.

The ban was justified on the grounds that the flavour masks the tobacco taste and encourages consumption, thereby posing a health threat.

The EU gave member states two years to implement the rule, and it took effect in Germany in 2016.

But it also granted extra time to manufacturers of products with a market share greater than 3 per cent until 2020, so they would have time to sell off their stock.

After this rule took effect in Germany in 2016, Planta Tabak sued on the grounds that this phase-out structure was discriminatory.

Berlin’s administrative court ultimately referred the case to the European Court of Justice (ECJ).

The Luxembourg judges rejected the firm’s claim, arguing that the phase-out period granted to member states to implement the regulation was enough for producers.

By allowing member states to determine whether a tobacco product reaches 3 per cent of market share, the ECJ said, the regulation granted enough legal certainty to manufacturers and therefore did not discriminate.

Moreover, the broader health objectives specifically, discouraging tobacco consumption by young people justified the regulation’s “restriction on the freedom of goods,’’ the Luxembourg judges wrote.

“Some flavourings are particularly attractive to young people and facilitate initiation of tobacco consumption,’’ they argued. The case now reverts to Berlin’s administrative court.

Ethiopia moves to actualise climate adaptation plan

0

The government of Ethiopia on Wednesday, January 23, 2019 hosted its first National Adaptation Plan (NAP) assembly, bringing together key government actors and development partners in dialogue on the transition to implementation of the country’s NAP.

NAP Assembly
NAP Assembly participants

Supported by the NAP Global Network, Ethiopia’s recently completed NAP provides an overarching framework for the country’s response to the impacts of climate change, complementing other elements of its climate change policy suite.

“NAP Assembly (is) an excellent opportunity to disclose our strategic initiatives, create synergies and transform our strategy and implementation of our NAP into actions through partnership and collaboration with development partners to build a more economically vibrant, socially inclusive and environmentally sustainable country,” said Professor Fekadu Beyene, Commissioner for Ethiopia’s Environment, Forest and Climate Change Commission.

“I view this meeting as a classic example of the collaborative efforts needed from stakeholders in assisting the efforts of our government to realise its ambition of reaching middle-income status before 2025,” he added.

As a next step, government actors and other stakeholders will develop a roadmap for implementing Ethiopia’s NAP.

“In moving towards the implementation phase of the NAP process, Ethiopia has demonstrated commitment to participation and consideration of gender issues, putting forth these important guiding principles that are enshrined in the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change,” said Angie Dazé, Associate with the NAP Global Network. “We are pleased to have been able to support them in these efforts.”

Stakeholders flay privatisation, seek workable water supply scheme

0

Over 150 participants from across the globe that converged on Abuja for a two-day National Summit on the Human Right to Water have carpeted the World Bank and short-sighted leaders of the African continent for promoting water privatisation schemes that have largely cut poor people off a basic human right and thrown their nations into debts.

ERA Water Summit
Local and international delegates sharing experiences at the National Summit on Water

The summit, with the theme: “Nigeria’s Water Emergency: From Resistance to Real Solutions Against Corporate Control”, was organised by the Environmental Rights Action/Friends of the Earth Nigeria (ERA/FoEN) in concert with Corporate Accountability, Public Services International and other groups on the platform of the Our Water Our Right Coalition.

Participants said that despite growing remunicipalisations as a result of failed promises by pro-privatisation forces, chief promoters of privatisation such as the World Bank and International Financial Corporation (IFC) have become more daring, as such, advocates must bond together to stop them.

In a keynote address titled: “The Nigerian Water Crisis and the Imperative of Rights-based Solutions”, Dr. Otive Igbuzor said that the July 28, 2010 General Assembly of the United Nations recognition of water and sanitation as basic human right entitles everyone to sufficient, safe, acceptable, physically accessible and affordable water for personal and domestic uses.

Igbuzor, who is Executive Director African Centre for Leadership, Strategy & Development (Centre LSD), said the recognition of this basic right also obligates the state to protect and prevent third parties from interfering with the rights to water and sanitation, including that government will making laws to ensure that providers or individuals comply with human rights standards related to the rights to water and sanitation.

Going into history, he said that the involvement of the private sector in water and sanitation issues since the late 1980s supposedly to enhance access has only increased the cost of water services since private firms charge full costs and must pay taxes and earn a profit.

He maintained that claims that privatisation would actually enhance service delivery compared with the public sector has been proven false and not supported by evidence emerging from cases in Africa, Europe and Latin America where private sector participation was strongly promoted.

“On the contrary, private sector participation has led to rising social inequality and the weakening of democratic governance and substantive citizenship in the management of water and sanitation services,” he said.

He stressed that while water is very important for life and human survival, the challenge is that the poorest of the poor do not have access to clean water and sanitation, hence a global water crisis and a Nigerian water crisis.

According to him, the Nigerian water crisis is exacerbated by the crisis of the Nigerian state which has gone beyond mediating the competing interest of elite groups or being an instrument of the ruling class to become an instrument of deception.

The result of this, he argued, is a dysfunctional and deceitful Nigerian state with crisis in all the sectors: Political, economic, social, educational, health, water, among others.

ERA Water Summit
L-R: Dr Otive Igbuzor (keynote speaker), Satoko Kishimoto (Transnational Institute), Shayda Naficy (Corporate Accountability) and Nnimmo Bassey (Chair of the board of ERA) and the summit

He concluded by reiterating that since the UN has recognised water and sanitation as a basic human right, the state has the obligation to respect, protect and fulfill the rights of their citizens to water and sanitation.

Earlier in a welcome address, Chair of the Board of ERA/FoEN, Nnimmo Bassey, said that the campaign against the privatisation of water has recorded notable milestones since the Lagos Water Summit that held in 2015. They include the growing synergy between labour and civil society organisations in resisting water privatisation and the expunging of anti-people sections of the Lagos Environment Law following opposing by the Our Water Our Right Coalition in 2017. 

Bassey revealed that beyond Lagos which the private water industry was interested in grabbing as a poster child, other African nations are also being primed for water privatisation.

Mr Taiwo Otitolaye, the Executive Director, Community Outreach for Development and Welfare Advocacy, an NGO, urged Nigerians to resist the privatisation and commercialisation of water.

“We must resist the privatisation and commercialisation of water; and in unison work together to realise clean, accessible and affordable water for all citizens, no matter where they reside. Water is a human right issue.

“Research across the states in Nigeria confirms a yearly recycle budgets on water by most state governments without utilising the budgeted funds for providing water to communities,’’ Otitolaye said.

Mr Mukaila Babarinde, the Head, Climate Change, Federal Ministry of Water Resources, noted that the role water played in all sectors of human development “cannot be over-emphasised’’.

He underlined the need for stakeholder collaboration and advocacy to sustain momentum to improve access to potable water, saying that Federal Government could not do it alone.

Babarinde said that efforts of government to improve access to potable water include the completion of abandoned water projects in the country and inauguration of the Partnership for Expanded Water Supply Sanitation and Hygiene programme.

He urged state governments to step up efforts to reticulate water from completed dams across the country to help in making water available for the populace.

Ms. Shayda Edwards-Naficy, the Senior Programmes Director, Corporate Accountability, noted that water crisis was a global crisis, saying there was the need for governments to prioritise access to potable water and sanitation facilities.

According to her, there is the need for all civil society groups to fight to promote human right to water.

“We are here to speak with one voice against privatisation and call for strong support for public water systems.

“We believe that the water problems that communities, states face are global in nature; there are struggles around corporations that stand against human rights across the globe, so we need to work together.

“Water needs to be in the hands of people, not corporations, movements around the world are demanding an end to the corporate control of this vital resource; it’s time.”

She said that there was presently a global solidarity to campaign for water justice for all, calling for governments and the World Bank to the heed calls and end the promotion of water for profit. That summit also had various sessions where grassroots groups from Lagos, Flint and Pittsburgh in the United States and India learned and shared experiences.

Reactions trail Germany’s 2038 coal phase-out plan

0

The Federal Government in Germany has announced plans to phase out coal by 2038.

Germany Coal
Germany will phase out coal in 2038

The Commission on Growth, Employment and Structural Change released a 20-year report which has agreed to cancel out coal by 2038.

With only one vote against, the commission agreed on a total of €40 billion in aid for the states affected by the coalition exit. The Federal Government will now turn the commission report into a reliable energy concept.

Olaf ScholzIf, Federal Finance Minister, said: “If we do not lose sight of the common goal, we can develop Germany into an exemplary state of energy policy.”

In the years 2023, 2026 and 2029, the Commission will undertake a review by an independent panel of experts.

In response to this review, the power plant capacity will be reduced to 17 gigawatts of brown coal and hard coal in 2030, more than halving it. Depending on the report, the withdrawal of coal could take place, according to the recommendation of the commission, by 2035.

Environment watchdog, Greenpeace, has called for this target to be brought forward to 2030 to ensure that carbon emissions are reduced sooner.

It was reported that, in 2018, the production of coal accounted for 38 per cent of Germany’s energy generation. This move away from fossil fuel generation will put Germany back on track to meet the targets set at the Paris Agreement.

This news follows a report that found that the immediate phase-out of fossil fuels is crucial to meet important climate targets.

The report found that if carbon intensive technologies were replaced by carbon-free alternatives, carbon emissions would steadily decline, dropping to near zero in 40 years. This would result in a 64 per cent chance of limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius.

In a reaction, physicist Hans Joachim Schellnhuber, a member of the Commission and Director Emeritus of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, said: “Germany is finding its way back to the climate protection path: the beginning of an orderly phase-out of coal-fired power generation has been made.

“This is an important step on the road to the post-fossil age – a step that also opens up new perspectives for the affected regions through innovation-driven structural change. The fact that the consensus was difficult to achieve, however, should not be concealed. Efficiency in the implementation and best possible use of taxpayers’ money should certainly also be the focus of the legislative processes that are now to follow.”

Economist Ottmar Edenhofer, Director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research and of the Mercator Research Centre on Global Commons and Climate Change, submitted: “It is necessary to take a second step on the road to stabilising our climate, now that the Coal Commission has taken an important first step. It is great that such a broad body, from industry to nature conservationists, has been able to agree to abandon coal. But it is only the necessary prerequisite, not yet sufficient, for substantially reducing our greenhouse gas emissions.

“However, some conservationists and quite a few business representatives share a tendency towards an unfortunately expensive planned economy. That is why we now need effective CO2 pricing in order to use market mechanisms to really secure the coal phase-out. A minimum price is conceivable in European emissions trading or in a pioneer coalition of Germany, France and the Netherlands. Smart CO2 pricing would also generate revenues with which the state can create more justice for all, instead of just making billions available for special interests.”

On his part, Earth system scientist Johan Rockström, Director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, stressed: “The whole world is watching how Germany – a nation based on industry and engineering, the fourth largest economy on our planet – is taking the historic decision of phasing out coal. This could cascade globally, locking in the fastest energy transition in history.

“This can help end the age of fingerpointing, the age of too many governments saying: why should we act, if others don’t? Germany is acting, even if the commission’s decision is not flawless. Yet it is a key contribution to limit the the increasing risks of for instance extreme weather events accross the world. To avoid crucial elements of the Earth system to tip, such as the huge ice sheets, we need social tipping points. Germany just passed one of these.”

Bali to impose ‘tourist tax’ for plastic pollution

0

The city of Bali in Indonesia has announced plans to implement a tourist tax which targets plastic pollution.

Bali
Picking discarded plastics in Bali

The Jakarta Post has reported that Bali has drafted a bylaw on tourist contributions for the environment and cultural preservation. The “tourist tax” will involve a fee of $10 for overseas visitors to the island.

The Indonesian island is a popular tourist destination and draws crowds of over four million people every year, but this has come at a cost. Bali is facing a plastic pollution crisis, producing over 3,800 tonnes of waste every day.

The island does not have a enough rubbish collection system and this has resulted in most rubbish being left on the island, buried in the ground, or ending up in the ocean.

Presently, over 12 million tonnes of plastic end up in oceans each year. As a result, over 90 per cent of sea birds have ingested plastic.

Bali has introduced the “go green” initiative to encourage visitors to think about the footprint they will leave behind.

Wayan Koster, Bali Governor, spoke outside the Bali Legislative Council building. He said: “This will give us better fiscal space to support the development of Bali.”

This comes after Bali banned a range of single-use plastics in December, including shopping bags, Styrofoam and plastic straws.

This news follows the European Union agreeing on deal for a single-use plastic ban, which could be put into place by 2021. The ban will target the 10 plastic products most often found on our beaches as well as abandoned fishing gear.

Courtesy: Climate Action

How to curtail cattle urine’s planet-warming power, by study

0

When cow urine falls on degraded land, it releases far more nitrous oxide – a potent greenhouse gas – than when absorbed by healthy pasture. The findings of a new study show additional benefits of landscape restoration and conservation.

Cattle rearing
For total livestock emissions, beef cattle is said to account for the highest methane emissions

The exceptional climate-altering capabilities of cattle are mainly due to methane, which they blast into the atmosphere during their daily digestive routine. Cattle urine is a lesser-known climate offender. It produces nitrous oxide (N2O), which has warming power far greater than that of carbon dioxide (CO2), the main driver of global warming. A study conducted by the International Centre for Tropical Agriculture (CIAT) and partners shows that these N2O emissions can be significantly curbed by healthy cattle pastures.

For the study, researchers collected urine from cattle at research sites in five countries across Latin America and the Caribbean. They spilled these 500 mL samples on paired cattle fields classified as degraded or healthy, which was determined by vegetation coverage. In six of the seven test sites, degraded pastures emitted significantly more N2O – sometimes up to three times as much. The results were published January 29, 2019 in Scientific Reports, an open-access journal by the publishers of Nature.

“Degraded pastures are bad in so many ways,” said Ngonidzashe Chirinda, a CIAT researcher and the study’s lead author. “This study adds to the case for land restoration. Degraded pastures not only affect food security and the livelihood of farmers today but affects the livelihood of future farmers because they emit more gases that cause global warming.”

The results add urgency to global land restoration agreements, including Initiative 20×20, which aims to bring into restoration 20 million hectares of land into restoration in Latin America by 2020 as a first major step toward even more ambitious restoration targets.

Estimates vary, but Chirinda calculates, conservatively, that there are 150 million hectares of degraded lands in Latin America. Brazil alone is home to some 80 million hectares of degraded pastureland.

Degraded livestock land is generally characterized by overgrazing, soil compaction, loss of organic material and low levels of nutrients and soil carbon. Large-scale land restoration with improved forage grasses, rotational grazing and the addition of shrubs and trees (silvopastoral farming) could significantly mitigate the negative climate effects wrought by degradation. In addition to reducing N2O emissions, restored landscapes generally contain more carbon, have healthier soils and more robust and productive livestock.

“This study highlights the importance of avoiding land degradation in the first place,” said Todd Rosenstock, a co-author based at the World Agroforestry (ICRAF). “Maintaining healthy pastures appears to reinforce goals of both the United Nations’ Framework Convention on Climate Change and the UN Convention to Combat Desertification simultaneously.”

The curious results from the single test site that did not align with the study results – in Taluma, Colombia – may be attributed to several factors that merit further research. N2O emissions there were by far the lowest at any test site and were the same on both degraded and healthy pastures. The cattle urine used in the experiment had the lowest nitrogen content compared to the other research sites, which likely contributed to the results. The forage grass used there, Brachiaria humidicola, also has an especially high nitrification inhibition capacity, meaning that it prevents nitrogen from becoming N2O.

Power of data from far-flung places
The study is a victory for well-designed, modest-budget science. The project began with a weeklong training session at CIAT headquarters in Cali, Colombia, where a team of Ph.D. students from the additional participating countries – Argentina, Brazil, Nicaragua and Trinidad and Tobago – helped design the research plan and standardised the study’s methodology.

The students returned to their home countries and carried out the experiment to coincide with their area’s rainy seasons, to assure similar climate conditions across study sites. (The exception was Taluma, which was sampled during a period characterised by low rainfall, which is also another possible reason why the N2O emissions were lower there).

“The power is in the number of data points from all the different countries,” said Chirinda.

Better cattle greenhouse gas estimates
Researchers said the study is a useful step toward creating a more detailed picture of the scope of greenhouse gas emissions from cattle farming in LAC.

“Since work on emissions from livestock in the region is not common, this study generates at least one piece of information that is missing from theoretical greenhouse gas estimates in the LAC region,” said Miguel Andrés Arango, a co-author and scientist at Colombia’s AGROSAVIA, the nation’s largest agriculture research organisation.

“Being able to estimate the real impact of cattle production will allow us to propose potential practices for reducing emissions,” said Arango. “It is high time we know the emission factors for our agricultural systems.”

Collaborators and funders
The study was conducted under the framework of the Latin America climate change Mitigation Network (LAMNET) and implemented as part of the CGIAR Research Program on Climate Change, Agriculture and Food Security (CCAFS), which is carried out with support from CGIAR Fund Donors and through bilateral funding agreements.

Collaborators on the project included researchers affiliated with the following organisations: the National Autonomous University of Nicaragua; the National Institute of Agricultural Technology in Argentina (INTA); the Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS) and the Institute of Agriculture and Forestry Management and Certification (IMAFLORA)  in Brazil; the University of the West Indies in Trinidad and Tobago; Universidad Nacional de Colombia; the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA); and the University of Vermont.

Adidas to produce 11m pairs of shoes made from recycled plastic in 2019

0

Sportswear manufacturer, Adidas AG, has announced its commitment to make 11 million pairs of shoes made from recycled plastic in 2019.

Adidas
Adidas footwear. Photo credit: Adidas

In 2018, Adidas produced five million shoes made from recycled plastic. This year, to curb the growing plastic pollution, the firm has committed to over doubling this figure.

Adidas has collaborated with Parley for the Oceans, a company that intercepts plastic from beaches before it can reach the oceans. This plastic is then upcycled and made into a yarn becoming a key component of the upper material of Adidas footwear.

Eric Liedtke, Adidas Executive Board member responsible for Global Brands, said: “With Adidas products made from recycled plastic, we offer our consumers real added value beyond the look, functionality and quality of the product, because every shoe is a small contribution to the preservation of our oceans. After one million pairs of shoes produced in 2017, five million in 2018, we plan to produce eleven million pairs of shoes containing recycled ocean plastic in 2019.”

Where the use of plastic is unavoidable, for example in transport packaging, Adidas is relying on counterbalancing measures and promoting sustainable alternatives.

It also supports the innovation platform Fashion for Good with a donation of €1.5 million, which equates to the company’s environmental impact of plastic packaging.

Gil Steyaert, Executive Board member responsible for Global Operations at Adidas, said: “Sustainability at Adidas goes far beyond recycled plastic. We also continue to improve our environmental performance during the manufacturing of our products. This includes the use of sustainable materials, the reduction of CO2 emissions and waste prevention. In 2018 alone, we saved more than 40 tons of plastic waste in our offices, retail stores, warehouses and distribution centres worldwide and replaced it with more sustainable solutions.”

This news follows Adidas signing the Climate Protection Charter for the Fashion Industry where it agreed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 30 per cent by 2030.

Courtesy: Climate Action

Lake Chad: Dambazau solicits stakeholders’ support on humanitarian crisis

0

Minister of Interior, Lt.-Gen. Abdulrahman Dambazau (retd), on Tuesday, January 29, 2019 solicited support of international donors and other stakeholders in alleviating humanitarian crisis around countries in Lake Chad Basin.

Lt.-Gen. Abdulrahman Dambazau
Minister of Interior, Lt.-Gen. Abdulrahman Dambazau (retd)

Dambazau made the appeal at the second Regional Protection Dialogue on Lake Chad Basin in Abuja.

He said that the cooperation of the stakeholders was imperative in ensuring that their efforts at alleviating the crisis in the region yielded positive results.

Earlier, at the meeting, UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) in collaboration with the Ministry of Budget and National Planning and the Ministry of Finance launched a Humanitarian Response Protection Plan.

The Plan is part of concrete measures to solidify efforts to alleviate the crisis in the region.

Dambazau recalled that a Tripartite Agreement among Nigeria, Cameroon and United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) was signed in March 2017.

He said that the agreement was to facilitate the voluntary return of Nigerian refugees living in Cameroon in a safe and dignified manner, adding that the process for the return of the refugees was ongoing.

“I do not need to tell you that it is not yet ‘Uhuru’ as far as the alleviation of the challenges of the Lake Chad Basin is concerned,” he said.

The minister noted that security in the basin had remained a challenge in spite of the efforts of the joint military forces of countries in the basin.

“In spite of the huge breakthrough achieved in the fight against the insurgents by efforts of our joint military forces, security in the Basin has remained a challenge, particularly for the displaced population and other vulnerable groups.”

He explained that the aim of the dialogue was for stakeholders to appraise the commitments toward the implementation of outcome of the first meeting.

“It is also to explore broader regional and international support towards comprehensive review of the protection situation in Lake Chad Basin countries.

“It is to reinvigorate consensus around protection considerations and principles as informed by international law and standard norms.

“It is also to propose and seek the adoption of a framework for comprehensive solutions that are in line with international principles,” he said.

The minister added that objective of the meeting was to identify the protection risk in the region resulting from conflict-induced crisis in the Lake Chad Basin and proffer appropriate practical solutions to redress them.

“It is also to provide practical solutions to the plights of the people in and around the Lake Chad region who were turned to refugees and Internally Displaced Persons due to insurgency in the region,’’ he said.

By Doris Esa

Kenya set to launch food safety authority

0

Kenya is set to launch the Kenya Food and Drug Authority (KFDA) to help promote food safety, a government official said on Tuesday, January 29, 2019.

Kenya farmer
A Kenyan smallholder farmer

Harry Kimutai, Principal Secretary of the State Department for Livestock, said this during a forum on milk quality and safety in Nairobi.

“The authority is expected to ensure that populations consume safe food as well as promote domestic and international trade in Kenyan products,’’ said Kimutai.

He said the authority would enforce regulations to help reduce cases of aflatoxin in milk and cereals, a condition that is currently blamed for the upsurge of cancer cases in the country.

The official noted that the bill leading to the formation of the authority has been discussed by the Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock, Fisheries and Irrigation and is due to be subjected to validation by stakeholders.

Kimutai said the government has developed an elaborate framework of dairy standards that cover all the major dairy products manufactured or traded locally.

“These standards cover safety requirements as informed and benchmarked on international standards such as those developed by the Codex Alimentarius Commission,’’ said Kimutai.

Kaduna reviews obsolete laws to combat desertification, climate change

0

The Kaduna State Government on Tuesday, January 29, 2019 said it had passed a bill to the legislative arm to review laws for proper protection of the state’s forest resources.

Nasir el Rufai
Nasir el Rufai, Governor of Kaduna State

Mr Anthony Kachiro, the Director of Forest Resources in the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry Development of the state, disclosed this to the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) on Tuesday in Kaduna, the state capital.

Kachiro, who doubles as the State Chairman, Task Force on Forest Protection, said that the new laws would replace the old ones that had become obsolete.

He said that the bill, when it became law, would provide a proper legal backing to the state officials in terms of sanctions, fines and prosecution of those encroaching in the state forest reserves.

According to the official, the state government is working in line with the international effort to tackle the effects of global warming and environmental hazard of desertification.

He said while the laws were being fine-tuned for proper enforcement, the state government had set up a task force with members drawn from the state timber and firewood dealers associations to tackle illegal felling of trees for local use and for business.

He said that the task force had recently impounded six trucks of firewood and timber being transported from Kasuwan Magani in Kajuru Local Government Area and Mi-Ido, near Ladugga in Kachia Local Government Area.

When asked if any arrest was made from the impounded vehicles, the official said: “No, we didn’t arrest anyone, but six vehicles from a particular vendor were impounded on their way from Ladduga.’’

“Those involved will be sanctioned and fined appropriately to ensure that the forests resources are protected,” Kachiro said.

He said that the task force was also monitoring those engaged in illegal felling of trees to make charcoal for business and proper sanctions would equally be applied on them to curtail their activities.

“We are working to ensure that for everyone tree that is cut down, at least three others are planted in the same area by the same person,” he said.

On the number of trees planted in 2018 in the state, Kachiro said that the ministry had concentrated in the maintenance and management of the trees planted in 2017 in its effort to tackle desertification.

The official, however, urged the state government to provide the task force with adequate security for proper discharge of its mandate.

By Shuaib Sadiq