The Community Court of the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) has imposed a N18 million fine against the Federal Government in judgment of a cases of violation of the fundamental human rights of one Dorothy Njemanze and two other Nigerians.
The court judgment read by Justice Friday Chijioke Nwoke of the three-man panel, after over 25 minutes, rendered the award of sums of N6 million each to parties: Justina Etim, Amarachi Jessyford and popular actress, Dorothy Njamenze to be paid by the Federal Government for the unlawfully arresting, detaining and declaring the parties as prostitutes in Abuja.
Justice Nwoke ordered the Nigerian government to pay the sums to the three ladies as compensation for humiliation and inhuman treatment they suffered during their arbitrary arrest and proclamation as prostitute.
Justice Nwoke held that the Nigerian government was liable for the arbitrary arrest and detention of the plaintiffs carried out by military operatives, police and officials of the Abuja Environmental Protection Board who claimed to be acting on the directive of the federal government.
The judge further held that the government’s pronouncement in declaring the three ladies commercial sex workers was a gross violation of their rights to dignity because there was no shred of evidence from the defendants for doing so other than mere suspicion that they were outside in the late hours.
The court agreed with counsel to the plaintiffs, Bolaji Gabari, that there was no law in the Nigerian statute book prohibiting women from being outside in the late hours. Besides, the court held that the defendant acted in bad faith and in gross violation of the fundamental rights of the plaintiffs to the freedom of movement by arresting and detaining them at the Gwarimpa Police Station in Abuja without informing them on the reasons for the arrest and without charging them to court for any known offence.
Justice Nwoke judgment further held that the violent, cruel, inhuman, degrading discriminatory and unlawful treatment meted out to the plaintiffs by the law enforcement agents of the Federal Government in Abuja was a condemnable act because the violation of rights of the plaintiffs to human dignity was carried out in breach of all known human rights laws.
He further held that from the totality of the evidence adduced during the hearing of the matter and from the totality of the claims of the plaintiffs, it is clear to the court that the action of the defendants was targeted at women in the discriminatory ways and manners, adding that when women are seen on the streets does not necessarily mean that they are prostitute except and unless there are cogent reasons and evidence to hold such a position.
The ECOWAS Court further said that the actions of the law enforcement agents against the plaintiffs were painful on the grounds that after the arrest of the plaintiffs and their dumping in detention, the Federal Government did not consider it necessary through its security agents to carry out thorough investigation on the arrested ladies to determine their status better merely went out of its way to pronounce them prostitutes without any cogent evidence.
He said: “The right to human dignity is the most fundamental human rights and unless legislation permits, no one must be deprived of the right to human dignity. In the instant case the action of the defendant runs contrary to all laws on human rights because the arbitrary arrest, detention and declaration of the plaintiffs as a class of prostitute was not premised on any known law.
“At any rate discriminatory treatment, cruel and inhuman treatment meted out to the plaintiffs in this case cannot be said to be in good faith for whatever reasons other than the fact that their fundamental rights to human dignity have been violently violated and as such each of the plaintiff is hereby awarded six million naira each to be paid by the defendant for the unlawful action against the citizens,” the judge held.
Justice Nwoke admitted that law enforcement agents under the law may have powers to make lawful arrest but such power to make lawful arrest becomes unlawful when the power of arrest is arbitrarily carried out, as in the instant case.
Reacting to the judgment outside the court, Dorothy Njamenze, who wept bitterly shortly after the judgment was handed down against the government, thanked the court for doing justice to the government’s unlawful claim of declaring her a prostitute.
She also expressed optimism that, with the judgment, the government will now do away with all laws and policies targeted at discriminating against the women folk.
Also reacting to the judgment, Chetach Loius Udeh, Progamme Officer, Gender Justice Project for Alliances for Africa, whose organisation coordinated the court action for the plaintiffs, pleaded with the Nigerian government to learn from the court judgment by dropping all actions aimed at exposing women to unnecessary ridicule, cruel, inhuman treatment and all forms of discrimination in the interest and fair play.
By Chinyere Obia